Study this example situation:
Tom is looking for his key. He can't find it.
He has lost his key. (present perfect)
This means that he doesn't have his key now.
Ten minutes later:
Now Tom has found his key. He has it now.
Has he lost his key? No, he has found it.
Did he lose his key? Yes, he did.
He lost his key (past simple)but now he has found it. (present perfect)
The present perfect (something has happened) is a present tense. lt always tells us about the situation now. 'Tom has lost his key' = he doesn't have his key now (see Unit 7).
The past simple (something happened) tells us only about the past. If somebody says 'Tom lost his key', this doesn't tell us whether he has the key now or not. lt tells us only that he lost his key at some time in the past.
Do not use the present perfect if the situation now is different. Compare:
- They've gone away. They'll be back on Friday. (they are away now)
They went away, but I think they're back at home now. (not They've gone)
- It has stopped raining now, so we don't need the umbrella. (it isn't raining now)
It stopped raining for a while, but now it's raining again. (not It has stopped)
|